Dress up as though you are the inanimate Halloween Decor for your lawn. Example: scarecrow, Frankenstein, etc. Be as still as you can. When someone walks by, jump out and scare the heck out of them. Another idea is to lay flat on the lawn, pretending to be in a grave marked with a tombstone. Imagine their surprise when you rise from the dead!
- Ring doorbell and say "canned goods or meat."
- Get dressed up, knock on door. When person answers, put candy into his bowl.
- Visit friends' houses and write on the mirror with your finger, delivering a scary message such as "I'm watching you!" Breathe on the mirror and you can see your words. Let it dry naturally. When your friend takes a shower, the words will appear again when the mirror fogs up.
- Give away fake, plastic turds for treats.
- Get dressed up so you are unrecognizable. Join a group of trick-or-treaters, preferably some you know. It will drive them nuts not knowing who you are.
- Decorate your yard with all things superstitious. Ladder, black cat, broken mirror, crows. Put the number 13 on your door.
- Dress up in a hospital gown and walk around at night saying "They think I'm crazy, but I'm not. They deserved to die. They can't take me back, etc, etc."
- Dress up, ring doorbell. When someone answers, say "pull my finger."
- Traditional, ring doorbell and run.
- Toilet paper your own yard and accuse someone else of doing it.
- Gather everyone's jack o' lanterns and line them up on the sidewalk in middle of the block.